Whoopi Goldberg and Stephen A. Smith Blame Women for Abuse, I Disagree
I have been asked (many times) about my opinion on domestic violence and physical aggression against women. My opinion is clear: no man should ever put his hands on a woman. Ever. Under any circumstance. Period. And, after ESPN First Take host Stephen A. Smith implied that women can somehow fend off physical and domestic violence, The View host Whoopi Goldberg expressed a very dissimilar viewpoint than me. I can’t say I am surprised but I am certainly disappointed.
Here is exactly what Smith said about Ray Rice‘s physical assault of his then-fiancee, Janay Palmer.
“It’s not about him, then. It’s about you, and here’s what I mean by that… I think that just talking about what guys shouldn’t do, we got to also make sure that you can do your part to do whatever you can do to make, to try to make sure it doesn’t happen.”
He clearly implied that a woman’s actions immediately preceding any physical violence could be partially to blame for the violence she subsequently encounters. He attempted to couch his words in his sanctimonious backstory but we all saw what he was really saying. He devalued the body of the black woman who was knocked unconscious by Rice. And, he basically turned the assault (and battery) into a cause and effect scenario as if Rice had no other choice but to hit Palmer. Accordingly, Smith has since been suspended for this comments and Rice was suspended for two games.
Ever the anti-womanist, here is Goldberg’s reaction to Smith’s comments.
She was incredibly adamant about making her point. Even when her co-hosts tried to walk her down off the ledge, she wanted to clearly emphasize that women have to stop assuming that men are chivalrous and therefore violent. In other words, men are dogs and they will beat women to death so we should turn necessarily down before fights get too heated…for self-preservation. You know because the absence of chivalry in one’s person means that void is supplanted by violence, anger, and physical aggression.
She has previously vocalized her opinion on women hitting men after a video was leaked of Solange going ham on Jay Z in a hotel elevator.
As though she were there, she put words into Solange’s and Jay Z’s mouths always finding a way to make Solange culpable for the fight which ensued. Not only that, she claimed that Jay Z had the “right” to hit Solange once she hit him. I personally believe that a right to defend one’s self is different than the right to hit someone. She sees them as one in the same.
The problem with Goldberg’s logic is that it says men are blameless when physically assaulting and battering women half their size – or anyone for that matter. It almost implies that a beating is “what we get” anyway.
Smith issued an apology this week calling his comments the “most egregious mistake of his career.”
“My words came across it is somehow a woman’s fault. This is not my intent. It was not what I was trying to say. Yet the failure to clearly articulate something different lies squarely on my shoulders. To say what I said was foolish is an understatement. To say I was wrong is obvious. To apologize, to say I’m sorry, doesn’t do the proper justice. But I do sincerely apologize.”
Now let me be clear here: I don’t think anyone should walk around hitting people, man or otherwise. But, I come at this from a very different perspective than either Smith or Goldberg.
I am a very large woman. Folks shush me when I say “large” and correct me with “tall.” But, that’s bull. I am large. I am over six foot three and haven’t been under 215 pounds since high school. That’s just a fact.
Every fight I ever had growing up was with boys. I never started the fights and I rarely lost them. But, my size made me a prime target for folks looking to establish – or even cement – their street cred. If they could knock me down, they figured no one would challenge them again. Luckily for me, that never happened.
I specifically remember two young women who attempted to fight me. One was in elementary school. Her name was Cynthia and she despised me. She harassed me for weeks and called me a “bitch” more often than she used my actual name. One day, I was sick of her verbal abuse. She kicked a ball across the yard and it was headed straight for me. Instead of grabbing it for her, I stepped out of the way and let it roll yards down the field. She was livid. She began the neckrolling verbal assault, finger in my face, demanding I go get her kickball. I laughed in her face. And, at about the twelfth “bitch” I calmly explained to her that if she called me that word one more time, I would slap the taste out of her mouth. She paused and said, “Bi-.” SLAP. It was almost involuntary. Put it this way, she never called me that word again.
Now, at the time, I was only eight years old. But, I knew my size meant that I couldn’t walk around slapping the taste out of girls’ mouths on the regular. My mother told me I had to be aware of my size and how dangerous it could be if I hit someone and hurt them. I got the message loudly and clearly.
It wasn’t until eighth grade that I figured out how to better handle those situations. A girl named Tiffany hated my guts for no real reason other than my presence probably annoyed her. One day, I put her backpack in the locker room showers instead of the closet where it belonged. It was rude but I was thirteen and thought it was funny. Then, almost the identical scenario to five years earlier jumped off. This time, instead of five-foot-five, I was six-foot-two. She was no more than four-foot-eleven and crunk as hell.
She stood as close to chest-to-chest with me as she could get. In all honesty, it was more like chest to abdomen. She called me names. She threatened me. I said nothing. Then, she hit me. Not in the face. I think she knew better. But, she hit my left arm. It really didn’t even hurt. I chuckled and told her to let it go. I told her she was too small to be starting fights with me. She hit me again attempting to draw aggression. I just looked her in her eyes and asked, “Are you done?”
And, although the instigators standing around waiting for a fight were disappointed, I was pleased to not have beat this pint-sized person to death.
Since then, I have never been in a physical altercation with a girl. Because of my size, I know it can mean life or death for anyone I might attack in anger and aggression. I am a woman and I know this to be a fact.
So, no one can tell me that a muscular man like Ray Rice who stands at five-foot-eight inches tall and over two hundred pounds hasn’t gotten that message. Should Palmer be assaulting him? No. Does he have to respond in kind? Certainly not. I figured that out at thirteen. No doubt we can all agree that adults know better. Anyone who argues differently is just part of the problem.
What are your thoughts? Are Smith and Goldberg right? Can women “provoke” violence?
Want More Convos Like This One?
Latest posts by Jenn M. Jackson (see all)
- We can’t exist anywhere so let’s just drop the “while Black” - May 12, 2018
- Reckoning, the Combahee River Collective, and Black Women’s History Month - April 2, 2018
- And then there are the ones we left behind… - March 14, 2018
- On being Black, being disposed of, and seeking status. - January 31, 2018
- Getting socks for Christmas: On the pain we carry from holidays past - December 23, 2017