Why Nicki Minaj and Taylor Swift Are Not the Same

nickiminajanacondaIt never fails. You mention the privilege of white people and they respond by noting how black people do racial things too so…But, the truth is: we’re black. White people are not. Pretending as if historical context means nothing here is disingenuous. Likewise, comparing Taylor Swift’s antics to Nicki Minaj’s new video “Anaconda” – while tempting and personally gratifying to many white people – is false equivalency and shameless straw grasping. In this case, race matters. Vitally. 

I recently wrote an article explaining that Taylor Swift’s cultural appropriation video for “Shake it Off” is problematic. I called it racist. I stand by that claim. Any video which intentionally frames certain dance styles (which are performed, produced, choreographed, and funded by all races of people) as “white” or “black” or “urban” or whatever is problematic. This isn’t the same as my claim that the Beatles were technically “white people music.” The Beatles actually were all white people, they worked with white producers and artists, and they targeted white audiences. Ballet,  however, has been performed by many people of color. Yet, in Taylor Swift’s video, there is intentional framing to exclude women of color from the ballet scene dangerously reinforcing social norms that black bodies cannot be associated with more refined, urbane, and traditional facets of American culture.

Now, when Taylor Swift scuttles around awkwardly mocking black women’s bodies, she is appropriating. This means she doesn’t belong to the racial, social, or sub-group she is attempting to embody. Instead, she is playing on some of the most polarizing and limiting aspects of said subgroup for entertainment purposes. In essence, she is “wearing blackness” to make a point about how absurd it would be for her to “act black.” Meanwhile, she is pigeonholing black women’s bodies as if we are incapable of performing lead for the American Ballet Theater (cough Misty Copeland cough).

Nicki Minaj, while I have continuously criticized her inauthentic body imaging and her intentional framing as the one-dimensional Hottentot Venus, has the right do whatever the hell she wants with her body. In her new video “Anaconda,” she spends pretty much the entire time half (or two-thirds) nekkid. Like, cheeks everywhere. I think she looks great and it is her prerogative to do so. Comparing her personal sexuality choices to the appropriation parade Taylor Swift, Katy Perry, or Miley Cyrus put on every few months has nothing to do with personal identity. In fact, each of them is visually “acting black” for fun.

Where Swift is putting on a costume, Minaj is being the woman she wakes up to be each morning. Where Swift jokingly hunches her shoulders and attempts to shake what she lacks for a backside, Minaj simply moves with the natural fluidity inborn in her DNA. Where Swift, Perry, and Cyrus emulate, Minaj simply is. She doesn’t have to pretend to be anything because she isn’t acting like anyone else. While she is certainly the provocateur and her one-dimensionality can be problematic for young girls with less sexual agency than she has, she has every right to flaunt her assets as she chooses.

sports-illustrated-swimsuit-cover-lead-600x450What this is certainly not about though is the fact that Nicki Minaj owns her sexuality. Googling “Cher butt” or “Madonna breasts” or “Sports Illustrated swimsuit” proves that there are plenty of hyper-sexualized white women who do too. Check out this cover of 2014 Sports Illustrated cover where Nina Agdal, Chrissy Teigen, and Lily Aldrige posed basically naked with the backsides directly in the camera’s lens. It is only when a black woman does it that it becomes a problem to the white mainstream.

The only criticism I maintain for artists like Rihanna and Minaj (not so much Beyoncé anymore) is that embodying the stereotype isn’t necessarily the straightest path to defeating it. I’m sure these women have depth and character beyond their stage presences, but it is the lack of true and complete public self that endangers young black women and girls seeking reflections of themselves in the world. Frankly, blonde hair and “British” accents don’t really do that.

I may catch heat for saying that and I don’t personally care. We all know that young women look upwards and outwards when traversing adolescence. We have all done it. This isn’t me saying these women should raise other people’s children. But, Minaj, Rihanna, Beyoncé, Swift, Perry, and Cyrus are all brands now. Becoming a mega-star means synergy of sorts. Sometimes the images, sounds, and trends these women create are completely inescapable. So, there is a bit of accountability there. How that manifests in terms of business choices, body image decisions, and music content is debatable but the accountability is there nonetheless.

No matter what our individual estimations about these young women’s bodies and visual decision-making, it is very clear Nicki Minaj and Taylor Swift are not the same. Implying Swift’s whiteness and inherent privilege are wiped away because she likes to pretend she is socially awkward is a cop out. It is yet another tool of white supremacy to assert that Swift has a right to masquerade as black women because black women exist.

Our existence isn’t a good enough reason to caricature our bodies, our features, our fashion choices or our womanhood. When white artists and audiences begin to understand this, they might find they’d rather just make money being their plain old selves like the rest of us.

The following two tabs change content below.

Jenn M. Jackson

Jenn M. Jackson, PhD is a co-Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Water Cooler Convos. She is a native of Oakland, CA. Jenn is a radical Black feminist scholar who believes none of us are free until all of us are free.

7 Responses

  1. hogwkB says:

    Cause the players gonna play, play, play, play, play

    And the haters gonna hate, hate, hate, hate, hate

    Baby, I’m just gonna shake, shake, shake, shake, shake

    I shake it off, I shake it off

  2. Nitasha says:

    Are you kidding me? I am a woman of color. And in NO way did Taylor Swift’s performance seem racist. In fact, absolutely NON of her music, or actions show that she is remotely racist or “trying to be black”. My ancestors were slaves as well. If you didn’t know, Nicki Minaj is half Indian, and half black. I am full Indian. My husband is as white as they come. Taylor Swift is one of the few GOOD role models left in Hollywood for young girl’s. I gladly let my girls listen to her. You are just being bitter and looking too deep into it. Life is short. Instead of looking at the negatives and the past, look forward and try to make a change in our world, instead of just blogging about it.

  3. Melissa says:

    When I saw the video I was… Confused. For lack of a better word. It definitely put people into neat little groups. I took ballet for years. I’m Black. Sometimes I was the only person of color in the class. Sometimes I wasn’t. But I was there. I also never idolized or tried to emulate anyone else while growing up. Debbie Allen was the only celebrity I really paid attention to back then.

  4. anon says:

    do u really think u understand white peoples intentions and attitudes so well when you have never even lived that experience? Guurl, u are arogant

  5. Henry smith says:

    HELLO EVERY ONE: this is to inform you about your favourite artist NICKI MINAJ new decision . this is a new way of telling my fans that i love them and am very happy whit them. i have create a chance which you can book me, in any invent off your choice . e.g birthday ceremony,club party s, marriage invent, shows invent. and any other activities of my propositional. and for those who have not gotten my gift.. this is very easy.just contact my manage on this EMAIL: HENRYSMITH869@YAHOO.COM, NOTE: this is for America and Europe only.

  6. ken help says:

    Hello every one, is your favorite artist Nicki Minaj, when i visited an orphanage home, i sure a lot of beautiful girls

    and boys, dieing of hunger. so now i have decided to build an offernage home, i have set up a committing so if you are

    intresterd of, donating financially to help the orphanage home.. to make them have a better life. you can contact the

    commiting on EMAIL: HENRYSMITH869@YAHOO.COM. NOT. a handsome reward await you

  7. John Jeffery says:

    There is something called truth and honor that reactionaries fear and legacy of mental slavery traditional culture in history of United States of America.